Chocolate chip cookies are my kryptonite. I'm always looking for the best that I've ever eaten. These come the closest. They are each five pounds of butter, sugar, and chocolate. They only come close because I don't think walnuts should be added to cookies ever. I will say that the Peanut Butter Chip Cookie is the best of that kind of ever eaten.
I'm just grateful this shop is on the UWS or it would be an everyday stop for me.
Disclaimer: I love the Milk Bar cookies but none of them can be classified as Chocolate Chip Cookies.